Last night, 21-year-old North Carolina singer-songwriter Ethan Regan brought his Young Regan Tour to Minneapolis' Fine Line Music Cafe. Though still early in his career, Ethan already has an impressive résumé, having released his debut album at just 16 years old. Since then, he's put out three more records, most recently Young Regan, the album that shares its name with his current tour.
Before Ethan took the stage, Los Angeles native Lily Kershaw delivered an opening set that ended up being one of the night's biggest surprises. Seated alone on a stool with nothing but her guitar, she immediately drew the audience in with her soft, elegant voice and deeply emotional songwriting. Between songs, she chatted directly with audience members, creating an intimacy that made the room feel remarkably small. While her understated approach was often captivating, the set could have used a bit more oomph or variation, as it lulled at a few points. I’m also not a huge fan of when a venue is pin-drop silent for more than a song, and her whole set felt like that.
I did enjoy the anecdote of Lily sharing how she ended up on the tour. Years ago, Ethan's mom introduced him to her music, and he became a fan long before the two ever crossed paths professionally. It felt fitting to see them sharing a stage all these years later.
When Ethan and his band emerged, the crowd was ready as they opened with "Young Regan." Despite only being familiar with one of his songs beforehand, "Fine China," I found myself enjoying much of the set. Fan favorites "Secrecy" and "Wildflowers" also made appearances, reminding the crowd why he first began building a loyal following. However, the night's biggest standout for me was "Closer to You." It was the song that lingered well after the show ended and the one I'll definitely be streaming moving forward.
That said, I couldn't shake the feeling that something was missing.
Maybe it's because I attend so many shows at Fine Line, or maybe it's because I wasn't arriving with a deep connection to the music, but I found myself focusing on the details. Fair or not, presentation matters. When an artist walks onstage dressed as though they're heading out for a camping trip in the woods, it can affect how the performance is perceived. Fans invest their time, money, and energy into these experiences, and I think it's reasonable to expect a certain level of intention in what they see onstage.
I also felt a bit of a disconnect from Ethan himself. Depending on the song, I alternated between thinking, "This guy is having the time of his life" and "Does he even want to be here?" That inconsistency made it harder for me to fully connect with the performance. Perhaps that's an unfair assessment, but when you're unfamiliar with an artist's catalog, you inevitably become more aware of the things beyond the music.
None of this takes away from the fact that the songs sounded great and the band delivered a strong performance. I genuinely enjoyed much of the music and came away with a greater appreciation for Ethan’s catalog than I had going in.
One unexpected highlight came from the back of the room, where a small group of concertgoers spent much of the night twirling and swing dancing together. It was impossible not to notice, and their carefree enthusiasm became one of the most memorable parts of the evening. More than once, I found my attention drifting toward them, and honestly, they ended up being one of my favorite parts of the night.
Still, while the concert was enjoyable in the moment, it didn't leave a lasting impression. The music was good, the musicianship was strong, and the crowd was clearly invested. But for me, the overall show felt more pleasant than memorable, and it's probably not one I'd actively seek out again.